Does Congestion Always Hurt? Managing Discount under Congestion in a Game-Theoretic Setting
By Rajib Saha, Sumanta Singha, Subodha Kumar
Information Systems Research | December 2021
DOI
doi.org/10.1287/isre.2021.1040
Citation
Saha, Rajib., Singha, Sumanta., Kumar, Subodha. (2021). Does Congestion Always Hurt? Managing Discount under Congestion in a Game-Theoretic Setting Information Systems Research doi.org/10.1287/isre.2021.1040.
Copyright
Information Systems Research, 2021
Share:
Abstract
We study a scenario where a buyer (e.g., Uber) buys cloud capacity from a seller (e.g., Amazon Web services) to run its business. One of the key factors that affects the quality of cloud services is congestion, and it has drawn considerable attention in recent years. Congestion leads to a potential loss of end users (e.g., riders and drivers of Uber) thereby adversely affecting the demand for cloud services. Discount has been a useful mean to stimulate demand and reward customer loyalty. However, in the presence of congestion, the effect of discount on demand is ambiguous. On the one hand, a higher discount leads to higher demand; on the other hand, higher demand can lead to higher congestion, thereby lowering the demand. Given that end users are both price and congestion sensitive, the choice of optimal discount under congestion is therefore not straightforward. Using a game-theoretic model, we study the dynamics between congestion and discount, and explore how congestion moderates both buyer's and seller's optimal decisions. Our results show that the buyer is not necessarily worse-off even when the end users are more intolerant to congestion. In fact, we find that when end-users are more congestion sensitive, the demand of cloud services can actually sometimes increase and the discount offered by the seller can decrease. These findings have important managerial implications on the seller's pricing and capacity decisions. We also observe that a lower cost of technology can sometimes hurt the buyer and the buyer can pass on lower benefit to end users. Moreover, given that the cloud services are prone to disruptions, buyer sources from multiple cloud vendors that further complicates the matter. We draw useful insights about the buyer's procurement decisions under congestion in a multi-cloud setup.

Rajib Saha is an Associate Professor of Information Systems at the Indian School of Business (ISB). He works broadly in the areas of Economics of IT and IT-enabled business models and data mining. His research explores questions related to crowds and platforms, pricing and operationalisation of digital goods, B2B contracts, network analytics, and more.

Prior to joining ISB, he taught graduate-level courses in the area of Operations Management and Information Systems at the University of Rochester, and worked in the IT industry for several years at organisations such as Oracle and Novell.

Professor Saha received his MS and PhD in Business Administration from the University of Rochester, New York and B.Tech. in Computer Science and Engineering from the Indian Institute of Technology, Kharagpur.

Rajib Saha
Rajib Saha